#224 More VC Fund Tax & QSBS Detail!
👋 Hi, I’m Doug! Welcome to @TheFundCFO crew! Every Tuesday/[Thursday], we publish VC/CFO insights that matter - highlights from notable VC GPs, LPs, and CFOs/finance pros. Check out our VC Fund Playbooks, Models, Budgets, & Compliance Checklists @ AirstreamAlpha Products!
Need more help? Check out Fund CFO Support provided by the Airstream Alpha Team.
Love what we’re doing? Consider upgrading to paid for deeper dives on Thursdays (most paid subscribers expense these insights!).
Top Recent Posts with High Views:
#219 Size Matters in VC (Cont'd) & DPI / Premium Carry Templates
#218 Size Matters: Small vs. Big VC (5x+ vs. 2x+), Lightspeed Returns Detail
QSBS: Qualified Small Business Stock, Simplified (2/6)
In our previous post, we talked about QSBS, showed a theoretical example, and listed some common pitfalls. Now, let’s take a deeper dive into the practical steps investors, founders, and employees can take to ensure they capture the full benefits of QSBS.
Quick Recap: What is QSBS?
Qualified Small Business Stock (QSBS) is a tax incentive that allows investors, founders, and employees to potentially exclude 100% of their capital gains (up to $10 million or 10x their investment, whichever is greater) from federal taxes when selling eligible stock. To qualify, a company must:
The company must be a domestic C corporation with gross assets under $50 million at the time of stock issuance. (this includes cash from the financing round, and is different from the company’s valuation).
Note: If a company’s assets ever exceed $50M, even if they later drop below this threshold, QSBS will not apply to any future share issuances.
At least 80% of the corporation’s assets must be used in active business operations.
Investors must hold the stock for at least five years to qualify for the exclusion.
The $1.6 Trillion Opportunity: QSBS in Action
According to Carta, QSBS-eligible shares account for a massive $1.6 billion in value across employees, founders, and investors. However, many stakeholders fail to properly track and report their QSBS eligibility, missing out on these tax savings.
Theoretical Impact of QSBS
To understand QSBS better, our friends at Sapphire showed a theoretical example: Consider Taylor, a founder who develops innovative AI technology for applying long-lasting lipstick. After initially funding her company at a negligible cost basis, she raises $5 million at a $20 million valuation. An angel investor, Travis, invests $1 million, while venture firm KC Capital contributes $4 million.
Four years and ten months later, Taylor receives a $100 million acquisition offer. After negotiating to close the deal post five-year mark, all investors leverage QSBS status, significantly reducing their federal capital gains tax burden.
Impact Breakdown:
Taylor: With an almost zero cost basis, she benefits from an additional $2 million in after-tax proceeds.
Travis: Gains an additional $800K in after-tax profits.
KC Capital: While not taxed at an individual level, GPs and LPs could collectively see an increase of $3.2 million in after-tax proceeds.
Although Taylor's percentage increase seems modest at 4%, her low cost basis results in substantial total savings. However, residents in high-tax states like California face limitations since they do not benefit from state-level QSBS exclusions.
How to Properly Capture QSBS Benefits (Harvey)
Our friend Chris Harvey recently outlined a streamlined process in his LinkedIn post to ensure investors and founders can take full advantage of QSBS. Here’s what you need to know:
Frontload the Effort
Since 95% of QSBS tracking happens upfront, it’s essential to ensure your investment documents include QSBS provisions from the start. Key steps:
• All NVCA equity deal documents should include QSBS language
• Save all financials from the Data Room
Maintain a Centralized “QSBS File”
Create & maintain a dedicated QSBS file for each investment:
• Final closing documents
• QSBS checklists/questionnaires
• Financial statements (before & after the time of investment)
• QSBS memos or status summaries
• Centralized tracking spreadsheet or QSBS softwareReport Your QSBS to Investors
Ultimately QSBS accrues to a fund's partners—transparency is key:
• Automate tracking with software (Carta, CapGains) for ongoing checks (also consider usefulness of QSBS attestation services)
• Alert tax advisors of qualifying investments early on
• Clearly communicate QSBS eligibility status to LPs
• K-1 Reporting: New IRS proposals (late 2023) will require dedicated codes and disclosure of QSBS gains and eligibility on Schedule K-1Other Considerations:
• Early M&A Planning: If a company is acquired before the five-year mark, investors have limited time (60 days) to roll over their gains under Section 1045. This is rare for VCs but can be valuable when managed proactively.
• Annual QSBS Portfolio Review: Instead of overwhelming portfolio companies with complex forms, conduct a simple annual review to check for QSBS-disqualifying changes.
• Use Your Information Rights: If you're a major investor, use your rights to request QSBS updates from the company regularly to avoid surprises.
That’s all for today folks! Thanks for your support and spreading the word! Share this on Twitter or LinkedIn to help grow “the crew!”